Pumpkin Apple Butter

Try this thick and delicious pumpkin-apple butter the next time you make homemade bread. Fresh bread spread with homemade apple butter (with pumpkin as the base) is a rich treat!

Rated:

Nutrition Information

COMBINE pumpkin, apple, Juicy Juice, sugar and pumpkin pie spice in medium, heavy-duty saucepan. Bring to a boil; reduce heat to low. Cook, stirring occasionally, for 1 1/2 hours. Serve with buttermilk biscuits, breads, corn muffins or hot cereal. Store in airtight container in refrigerator for up to 2 months.

Recipe makes 3 cups.

Number of reviews: 178

jessica sioux city,iowa
my kids liked it! thumbs up in my house

Rated: 3

Cindy Rodriguez Avondale, AZ
Easy to make and so delicious. I tried it in the crockpot as suggested by the previous baker and she is right... it's good!

Rated: 5

Carrie Johnson Pearl City, HI
I have been searching for a couple of years now for a pumpkin butter recipe. I figured it had to be easy. Now I've found it and can share it with friends and family. It's not overly sweet and retains its pumpkin flavor. Thank you!

Rated: 5

Sarah Lirley McCune ,
This is a good recipe, with just the right amount of sweetness--and low calorie, too!

Rated: 4

Debbe Burke
My daughter had made this for Thanksgiving and I decided to try it. My tweak is to make it in my small crock pot. I cooked it on low for 5 hours. Perfect!

Rated: 5

robin leclerc port st. lucie, fla
this will become one of the recipes i make each fall for my family and friends...it's wonderful with cinnamon tortilla batwings..(tortilla cutouts sprinkled with cinnamon and baked)......we are having that combo for our pumpkin carving party...try it

Rated: 5

dj sickerott Conshohocken, PA
my family really loved this receipe will make it again soon

Rated: 4

Dawn Rice Council Bluffs, IA
This is a great recipe! I made it for the Child Care children here at my house, not only provides a full serving of fruit/Vegetable for snack it is wonder full to dip apples or wheat thins in. Children love it and so do I for that matter. I will also be making this to go along with my fruit and bread tray for Easter.

Rated: 5

Debbie DeBartolo Rocky Ford, CO
This is so easy to make and it's delicious. I'll have to double the recipe next time! My family wiped it out.

Rated: 5

nikki pals Palatine, IL
I made a puppkin nut bread to bring to work. I wanted to bring something to go with it. I found several recipes on this site and I sure am glad I chose this one! I did a few minor adjustments, I cut back a little on the sugar and I used 2 grated apples and a little water since I did not happen to have apple juice in the house. (nothing like planning ahead!) Any way it is/was fantastic, had every one asking for both recipes but it was the pumpkin butter that everyone commented on. It tastes better thatn the expensive ones that are in all the little specialty stores this time of year. This will be a keeper recipe. Oh, and try it in a baked apple, very good. A friend tried it in baked acorn squash, she said it was wonderful.

Rated: 5

Apirl Jones HOUSTON, TX
this was comforting and familiar yet different.

Rated: 4

LeaAnn Thornsberry NEWARK, OH
WOW!!! I have been making this for a few years now and people have come to expect it! It is soooo easy and sooo delicious and I just love that it makes great gifts in a jar or for in baskets for neighbors and friends especially at Thanksgiving!

Rated: 5

Sandra Behn BALTIMORE, MD
Worth the time it takes to make, and goes good with the apple.

Rated: 5

Paul Brown WEST WARWICK, RI
Wow!! the delicious taste of two Special Flavors. Thank You for a high Quality Recipe, This is a new favorite in our family.

Rated: 5

Wanda Tew BEDFORD, PA
I made this to give as gifts and it was a rave. Very easy to make and it tastes delicious. So glad I tried it.

Rated: 5

Back to Recipes Main